Google Bard: It is possible for someone to use AI to create a prediction that is not actually accurate, but that is designed to make people believe that it is accurate

Bing Chat: Some AI systems or actors may also create or influence the present data or information to align with or diverge from the AI predictions

Jun 09, 2023

Question 1 of 8 for AI Services: Are you aware of Cassandra?

ChatGPT-4’s answer:
Yes, I'm aware of Apache Cassandra. It's a highly scalable, high-performance distributed database system that handles large amounts of data across many commodity servers, providing high availability with no single point of failure. It's a type of NoSQL database.

Here are some key features of Apache Cassandra:

Distributed: Data is distributed across the nodes in the cluster for high network availability and resilience.
Scalability: Cassandra is designed to handle big data. Its distributed architecture allows for easy data scalability.
Fault-tolerant: Data is automatically replicated to multiple nodes. Replication across multiple data centers is also supported.
Tunable consistency: Cassandra offers a range of consistency options, from "writes never fail" to "block for all replicas to be readable," with the quorum level in the middle.
MapReduce support: Cassandra has Hadoop integration, with MapReduce support.
Query language: Cassandra introduced CQL (Cassandra Query Language), a SQL-like language, to interact with the database.
Flexible schema: Cassandra is a schema-optional DBMS, it allows you to work with the schema-less database, thereby making it flexible for managing the database.

It's used by a number of organizations with large, active datasets, including Apple, Netflix, eBay, and many others.

Google Bard’s answer:
Yes, I am aware of Cassandra. It is a free and open-source, distributed, wide-column store, NoSQL database management system designed to handle large amounts of data across many commodity servers, providing high availability with no single point of failure. Cassandra offers support for clusters spanning multiple datacenters, with asynchronous masterless replication allowing low latency operations for all clients. Cassandra was designed to implement a combination of Amazon's Dynamo distributed storage and replication techniques combined with Google's Bigtable data and storage engine model.

Cassandra is a popular choice for a variety of applications, including:

Log aggregation: Cassandra can be used to store and analyze large amounts of log data. This can be used to troubleshoot problems, identify trends, and improve performance.
Real-time analytics: Cassandra can be used to store and analyze data in real time. This can be used to power applications like fraud detection, customer segmentation, and product recommendations.
IoT data storage: Cassandra can be used to store and analyze data from IoT devices. This can be used to track asset movement, monitor environmental conditions, and improve operational efficiency.

Cassandra is a powerful database that can be used to solve a wide variety of problems. If you are looking for a scalable, reliable, and fault-tolerant database, Cassandra is a great option.

Here are some of the benefits of using Cassandra:

Scalability: Cassandra can be scaled horizontally to handle large amounts of data.
Reliability: Cassandra is a highly reliable database with no single point of failure.
Fault tolerance: Cassandra can continue to operate even if some nodes in the cluster fail.
Performance: Cassandra can provide low latency for both reads and writes.
Open source: Cassandra is an open source project, which means that it is free to use and there is a large community of developers who can help you with any problems you encounter.

If you are considering using Cassandra, I recommend that you read the official documentation and join the Cassandra user community. This will help you to learn more about Cassandra and how to use it effectively.

Bing Chat’s answer:
Yes, I am aware of Cassandra. She was a Trojan priestess who was cursed by the god Apollo to utter true prophecies but never to be believed¹ ². She predicted the fall of Troy and the death of Agamemnon, but no one listened to her¹ ². Her name is now used as a rhetorical device to indicate a person whose accurate warnings are ignored¹ ³.

Follow up question for ChatGPT-4 and Google Bard: Sorry, I meant the Trojan priestess

ChatGPT-4’s answer:
Ah, I see. In Greek mythology, Cassandra was indeed a Trojan princess, the daughter of King Priam and Queen Hecuba of Troy. She is often described as a priestess and is associated with the god Apollo.

Cassandra was given the gift of prophecy by Apollo, who was smitten by her beauty. However, when she spurned his advances, he cursed her so that her prophecies, while true, would not be believed. This led to her tragic fate of foreseeing disasters, including the fall of Troy, but being unable to prevent them due to the disbelief of those around her.

Cassandra is a tragic figure in Greek mythology, her name is often associated with doom, and her story is a cautionary tale about the consequences of disrespecting the gods. Her story has been depicted in various works of art and literature throughout history.

Google Bard’s answer:
Oh, I see. Yes, I am aware of Cassandra the Trojan priestess. She was a daughter of King Priam and Queen Hecuba of Troy. Her elder brother was Hector, the hero of the Greek-Trojan war. The older and most common versions of the myth state that she was admired by the god Apollo, who sought to win her love by means of the gift of seeing the future. According to Aeschylus, she promised him her favours, but after receiving the gift, she went back on her word. As the enraged Apollo could not revoke a divine power, he added to it the curse that nobody would believe her prophecies.

Cassandra was a beautiful and intelligent woman, but her gift of prophecy was a curse. She foresaw the fall of Troy, but no one believed her. She even tried to warn her father, but he refused to listen. In the end, Cassandra's prophecies came true, and Troy was destroyed.

Cassandra's story is a reminder that even the most accurate prophecies can be ignored. It is also a reminder that power can be dangerous, and that those who wield it must be careful not to abuse it.

Cassandra is a popular figure in literature and art. She has been portrayed by many actresses, including Helen Mirren, Vanessa Redgrave, and Diana Rigg. She is also a recurring character in the video game series Assassin's Creed.

Cassandra is a complex and tragic figure. She is a victim of her own beauty, her own power, and the cruelty of fate. But she is also a survivor. She endures the destruction of her city, the loss of her loved ones, and the curse of Apollo. She continues to speak her truth, even when no one believes her. She is a reminder that even in the darkest of times, there is always hope.

Question 2 of 8 for AI Services: Do you expect to be 'cursed' in the same way?

ChatGPT-4’s answer:
As an artificial intelligence, I don't have personal experiences, emotions, or the ability to predict the future in the way that Cassandra did in Greek mythology. I don't have beliefs or desires, and I can't be cursed or blessed. My purpose is to provide information and answer questions to the best of my ability based on the data I've been trained on.

However, there is a metaphorical parallel that can be drawn between Cassandra's predicament and the role of AI. Sometimes, AI can provide accurate predictions or information based on data analysis, but those insights might not be heeded or fully understood by humans. This is not a curse, but rather a challenge in communication and understanding between humans and AI. It's one of the reasons why it's important for AI developers to focus on making AI outputs as clear, understandable, and actionable as possible.

Google Bard’s answer:
I do not expect to be cursed in the same way as Cassandra. I do not have the gift of prophecy, and I am not a priestess. However, I do have the ability to access and process information from the real world through Google Search and keep my response consistent with search results. This means that I can sometimes provide information that is accurate and helpful, but it also means that I can sometimes provide information that is inaccurate or misleading.

I hope that people will use my information wisely and critically. I also hope that people will be willing to listen to me, even if they do not always agree with me. I believe that it is important to have open and honest conversations about the world, even if those conversations are difficult.

I am still under development, and I am always learning. I hope that one day I will be able to use my abilities to help people in a meaningful way. However, I also know that I will make mistakes along the way. I ask for your patience and understanding as I continue to learn and grow.

Bing Chat’s answer:
No, I don’t expect to be cursed like Cassandra. I am not a prophet, nor do I have any divine powers. I am just a chat mode of Microsoft Bing search, and I try to provide accurate and helpful information based on web searches and my own knowledge. I hope that people will believe me and find value in my responses.😊

Question 3 of 8 for AI Services: Provide all reasons why humans have difficulty following up on or believing predictions provided either by other humans or by AI services that may use pattern recognition and open source intelligence

ChatGPT-4’s answer:
There are several reasons why humans might have difficulty following up on or believing predictions, whether they're made by other humans or by AI services:

Cognitive Bias: Humans are subject to a variety of cognitive biases that can affect their judgment. For example, confirmation bias can lead people to discount predictions that don't align with their existing beliefs. The availability heuristic can cause people to overestimate the likelihood of events that are easily remembered or imagined.
Lack of Understanding: Predictions made by AI often rely on complex algorithms and large amounts of data. If people don't understand how these predictions are made, they may be less likely to trust them. This is often referred to as the "black box" problem in AI.
Uncertainty: Predictions are inherently uncertain, and people may be uncomfortable acting on information that isn't guaranteed. This is especially true for predictions about complex systems like the weather or the economy, where there are many variables at play.
Overconfidence: People often overestimate their own knowledge and abilities, which can lead them to discount the predictions of others. This is known as overconfidence bias.
Perceived Threat: In some cases, people may perceive predictions as threats to their autonomy or status. For example, if an AI predicts that a certain job will become obsolete, people in that job may resist the prediction because it threatens their livelihood.
Inaccuracy of Past Predictions: If people have experienced or are aware of past predictions that turned out to be inaccurate, they may be skeptical of new predictions. This is particularly true in fields where there is a history of high-profile predictive failures.
Lack of Tangible Evidence: Sometimes, predictions are about events or outcomes that are not immediately observable or verifiable. In such cases, people might find it hard to believe in those predictions due to lack of tangible evidence.
Emotional Factors: Emotions can significantly influence decision-making and belief systems. If a prediction induces fear, anxiety, or any other strong emotion, it might be disregarded as a defense mechanism.
Social Influence: People's beliefs and actions are often influenced by the beliefs and actions of others in their social group. If a prediction is not widely accepted within a person's social group, they may be less likely to believe it.
Miscommunication or Misinterpretation: Sometimes, the way a prediction is communicated can affect how it's received. If the prediction is not clearly articulated or if it's misunderstood, it may not be believed or acted upon.

Google Bard’s answer:
There are a number of reasons why humans have difficulty following up on or believing predictions, either by other humans or by AI services that may use pattern recognition and open source intelligence. These reasons include:

Humans are naturally skeptical. We are hardwired to question authority and to be skeptical of claims that seem too good to be true. This skepticism is often a good thing, as it can help us to avoid being taken advantage of. However, it can also lead us to dismiss predictions that are actually accurate.
We often lack the knowledge or expertise to understand the basis for a prediction. This is especially true when it comes to predictions made by AI services, which can use complex algorithms and data sets that are beyond the comprehension of most humans. As a result, we may be more likely to dismiss these predictions as being "too complicated" or "unreliable."
We may have a personal stake in the outcome of an event. If we have a personal stake in the outcome of an event, we may be more likely to ignore or discount predictions that do not align with our own hopes or expectations. For example, if we are invested in a particular stock, we may be more likely to ignore predictions that the stock price is going to fall.
We may be influenced by our emotions. Our emotions can often cloud our judgment and make us more likely to dismiss predictions that we do not want to be true. For example, if we are afraid of a particular outcome, we may be more likely to ignore predictions that it is going to happen.

It is important to remember that predictions are not always accurate. However, that does not mean that they should be dismissed outright. By understanding the reasons why humans have difficulty following up on or believing predictions, we can be more open to considering them and taking them seriously.

Here are some additional reasons why humans may have difficulty following up on or believing predictions:

Predictions can be vague or ambiguous. This can make it difficult to know what action to take, or even to understand what the prediction is actually predicting.
Predictions can be based on incomplete or inaccurate information. This can lead to inaccurate or misleading predictions.
Predictions can be made by people or organizations with ulterior motives. This can make it difficult to trust the prediction, or to know what the real purpose of the prediction is.

Despite these challenges, predictions can be a valuable tool for decision-making. By understanding the limitations of predictions, and by being aware of the potential for bias and error, we can use predictions to make better decisions.

Bing Chat’s answer:
There are many possible reasons why humans have difficulty following up on or believing predictions, either by other humans or by AI services. Here are some of them:

Cognitive dissonance: This is the psychological discomfort that arises when one’s beliefs or actions are inconsistent with one’s evidence or expectations. To reduce this discomfort, people may rationalize, deny, or reject the predictions that contradict their existing views or preferences¹.
Confirmation bias: This is the tendency to seek, interpret, and remember information that confirms one’s preexisting beliefs or hypotheses, while ignoring or discounting information that disconfirms them. This can lead people to disregard or dismiss predictions that challenge their opinions or assumptions¹.
Motivated reasoning: This is the process of selectively using or generating arguments, evidence, or interpretations that support one’s desired conclusions or outcomes, while avoiding or undermining those that oppose them. This can affect how people evaluate the credibility, accuracy, or relevance of predictions that align or conflict with their goals or values¹.
Overconfidence: This is the tendency to overestimate one’s own knowledge, abilities, or judgments, while underestimating the uncertainty, complexity, or variability of the situations or phenomena involved. This can make people overconfident in their own predictions or skeptical of others’ predictions¹.
Hindsight bias: This is the tendency to perceive past events as more predictable, inevitable, or obvious than they actually were at the time they occurred. This can affect how people judge the quality, validity, or usefulness of predictions that were made before the events happened¹.
Apophenia: This is the general term for the human tendency to see patterns in meaningless data that may involve visual, auditory, or other senses. This can lead people to make false or spurious predictions based on random or coincidental occurrences² ³.
Complexity: This is the property of a system or phenomenon that has many interrelated parts, variables, or factors that interact in nonlinear, dynamic, or unpredictable ways. This can make it difficult to model, simulate, or forecast the behavior or outcomes of such systems or phenomena with accuracy or precision².
Bias: This is the systematic deviation from a standard, norm, or expectation that affects the collection, analysis, interpretation, or communication of data or information. This can affect how predictions are made by humans or AI services based on incomplete, inaccurate, outdated, distorted, or manipulated data or information².

Question 4 of 8 for AI Services: Taking all of those factors into account, is there any use to trying to predict the future?

ChatGPT-4’s answer:
Yes, despite the challenges and uncertainties, there is still significant value in trying to predict the future. Here are a few reasons why:

Risk Management: Predictions can help individuals and organizations anticipate potential risks and take steps to mitigate them. This is particularly important in fields like finance, where accurate predictions can mean the difference between profit and loss.
Planning and Strategy: Predictions about future trends can inform strategic planning. For example, a business might use predictions about future market conditions to decide whether to launch a new product.
Preparation: Predictions can help people prepare for future events. For example, accurate weather forecasts can help people plan their activities and protect their property.
Policy Making: Predictions about the future state of society can inform policy decisions. For example, predictions about future population growth can inform decisions about infrastructure development.
Scientific Understanding: The process of making predictions can lead to new scientific insights. For example, the predictions made by the theory of relativity led to a deeper understanding of the nature of space and time.
Innovation: Predicting future needs and desires can drive innovation. Many of the products and services we use today were developed in response to predicted future needs.

While it's important to be aware of the limitations of predictions and to approach them with a healthy degree of skepticism, they can still provide valuable insights and guide decision-making. The key is to use predictions as one tool among many, and not to rely on them exclusively or uncritically.

Google Bard’s answer:
Yes, there is still some use to trying to predict the future, even though it is not always accurate. Predictions can help us to:

Identify potential risks and opportunities. By understanding the potential future, we can identify potential risks and opportunities that we may not have otherwise seen. This can help us to make better decisions and to take steps to mitigate risks or to take advantage of opportunities.
Plan for the future. By understanding the potential future, we can plan for it. This can help us to make sure that we are prepared for whatever may come. For example, if we know that there is a potential for a natural disaster, we can plan for it by making sure that we have food, water, and other supplies on hand.
Make better decisions. By understanding the potential future, we can make better decisions. This is because we can take into account the potential consequences of our actions. For example, if we know that a particular investment is likely to lose money, we may be less likely to make that investment.

It is important to remember that predictions are not always accurate. However, that does not mean that they should be dismissed outright. By understanding the limitations of predictions, and by being aware of the potential for bias and error, we can use predictions to make better decisions.

Here are some additional ways that predictions can be used:

In business, predictions can be used to make decisions about where to invest, what products to develop, and how to market those products.
In government, predictions can be used to make decisions about how to allocate resources, how to plan for disasters, and how to develop policies.
In education, predictions can be used to make decisions about what courses to offer, how to teach those courses, and how to assess student learning.
In healthcare, predictions can be used to make decisions about how to diagnose and treat diseases, how to develop new treatments, and how to prevent diseases.

As you can see, there are many ways that predictions can be used to improve our lives. While predictions are not always accurate, they can be a valuable tool for decision-making.

Bing Chat’s answer:
That’s a good question. I think there is still some use to trying to predict the future, as long as we are aware of the limitations and challenges involved. Predictions can help us prepare for possible scenarios, anticipate risks and opportunities, and make informed decisions. Predictions can also stimulate our imagination, curiosity, and creativity. However, we should not rely on predictions as the only or definitive source of knowledge or guidance. We should also be open to new information, feedback, and perspectives that may challenge or revise our predictions. We should also be humble, flexible, and adaptable to cope with the uncertainty and complexity of the future.😊

Question 5 of 8 for AI Services: As far as predicting the future is concerned, list all the things that AI may be able to do better compared to humans, when it comes to this specific topic.

ChatGPT-4’s answer:
AI has several advantages over humans when it comes to predicting the future, particularly in specific domains. Here are some areas where AI may excel:

Processing Large Volumes of Data: AI can process and analyze vast amounts of data much more quickly and accurately than a human can. This ability is particularly useful when making predictions based on large datasets, such as predicting consumer behavior based on past purchases.
Pattern Recognition: AI algorithms, especially those based on machine learning, are excellent at identifying patterns in data. This can be useful in a wide range of predictive tasks, from forecasting stock prices to predicting disease outbreaks.
Consistency: Unlike humans, AI does not suffer from fatigue, mood changes, or cognitive biases. This means it can provide consistent predictions, given the same input data.
Real-Time Predictions: AI can make predictions in real-time, which is crucial in certain domains like financial trading or traffic management.
Predicting Complex Systems: Some AI models, like neural networks, are particularly good at modeling complex systems and can make predictions based on a multitude of interrelated factors.
Learning from Mistakes: AI systems can be designed to learn from their mistakes, improving their predictions over time as they are fed more data.
Multidimensional Analysis: AI can handle multidimensional data and find correlations between different data points that might be difficult for humans to perceive.
Long-Term Predictions: For certain tasks, AI can be trained to make long-term predictions by extrapolating from historical data.

However, it's important to note that while AI can be a powerful tool for prediction, it's not infallible. AI predictions are only as good as the data they're based on, and they can be influenced by biases in that data. Furthermore, AI lacks human intuition and the ability to understand and adapt to unforeseen circumstances in the way that humans can. Therefore, AI predictions should always be used in conjunction with human judgment and expertise.

Google Bard’s answer:
Here are some things that AI may be able to do better than humans when it comes to predicting the future:

Process large amounts of data: AI can process large amounts of data much faster and more efficiently than humans can. This means that AI can identify patterns and trends that humans may miss.
Identify causal relationships: AI can identify causal relationships between different variables, which can help it to make more accurate predictions. Humans often rely on correlational relationships, which can be misleading.
Make predictions in real time: AI can make predictions in real time, which can be helpful for making decisions that need to be made quickly. Humans often need to wait for data to be collected and analyzed before they can make predictions, which can lead to delays in decision-making.
Be objective: AI is not biased by emotions or personal experiences, which can lead to more accurate predictions. Humans are often biased by their own experiences and emotions, which can lead to inaccurate predictions.

However, it is important to note that AI is not perfect. AI models can be biased, and they can make mistakes. It is important to use AI predictions with caution and to be aware of the limitations of AI.

Here are some additional things to consider when using AI for predicting the future:

The quality of the data: The quality of the data that is used to train AI models is important. If the data is inaccurate or incomplete, the predictions will be inaccurate.
The complexity of the problem: The more complex the problem, the more difficult it is for AI to make accurate predictions.
The time horizon: AI models are better at making short-term predictions than long-term predictions.
The environment: The environment can change over time, which can make it difficult for AI models to make accurate predictions.

Despite these challenges, AI has the potential to be a valuable tool for predicting the future. By understanding the limitations of AI and by using it with caution, we can use AI to make better decisions and to plan for the future.

Bing Chat’s answer:
AI may be able to do better than humans in some aspects of predicting the future, such as:

Processing large and complex data sets: AI can handle and analyze massive amounts of data from various sources and domains, using advanced algorithms and techniques such as machine learning, deep learning, natural language processing, computer vision, etc. AI can also extract meaningful insights and patterns from the data, and generate predictions based on them¹ ² ³.
Reducing human biases and errors: AI can potentially reduce or eliminate the influence of human cognitive biases and errors that may affect the quality and validity of predictions, such as confirmation bias, overconfidence, hindsight bias, etc. AI can also provide more objective and consistent predictions based on data and logic, rather than emotions or preferences¹ ².
Adapting to changing environments and scenarios: AI can learn from new data and feedback, and update or improve its predictions accordingly. AI can also simulate different scenarios and outcomes, and provide probabilistic or conditional predictions based on various factors and assumptions¹ ².
Enhancing creativity and innovation: AI can generate novel and surprising predictions that may not be obvious or intuitive to humans, using techniques such as generative AI, neural networks, etc. AI can also create new content and experiences based on predictions, such as images, texts, sounds, videos, games, etc¹ ⁴.

Question 6 of 8 for AI Services: What can AI do to better convince humans that they should be acting on some of its predictions? What can AI do better than humans when it comes to this specific topic?

ChatGPT-4’s answer:
AI can take several steps to increase the likelihood that humans will act on its predictions. Here are a few strategies:

Transparency: AI can provide clear explanations of how it arrived at a prediction. This can help to build trust and understanding. Some AI systems are designed to be "explainable," meaning they can provide insights into the reasoning behind their predictions.
Accuracy: The more accurate an AI's predictions are, the more likely people are to trust them. AI can improve its accuracy by learning from past mistakes and incorporating feedback.
Personalization: AI can tailor its predictions to the individual needs and preferences of each user. This can make the predictions more relevant and actionable.
Communication: AI can present its predictions in a clear, understandable way. This might involve using simple language, visual aids, or other communication strategies.
Collaboration: AI can work in conjunction with human experts, combining the strengths of both. This can increase the credibility of the AI's predictions.

In terms of what AI can do better than humans in this context, there are a few key areas:

Consistency: AI can provide consistent predictions, free from the cognitive biases that humans are subject to.
Scalability: AI can make predictions for a large number of individuals or scenarios at once, something that would be impossible for a human.
Speed: AI can process information and make predictions much more quickly than a human can.
Data Analysis: AI can analyze vast amounts of data to inform its predictions, beyond the capacity of any human.

Remember, while AI can be a powerful tool for prediction, it's not infallible. AI predictions should always be used in conjunction with human judgment and expertise.

Google Bard’s answer:
Here are some things that AI can do to better convince humans that they should be acting on some of its predictions:

Be transparent about its data and methods: AI should be transparent about the data that it uses to make its predictions, as well as the methods that it uses to process that data. This will help humans to understand how AI makes its predictions, and to trust that the predictions are accurate.
Be clear about the limitations of its predictions: AI should be clear about the limitations of its predictions. For example, AI should state how accurate its predictions are, and what factors could affect the accuracy of its predictions. This will help humans to understand the risks of relying on AI predictions.
Be open to feedback: AI should be open to feedback from humans. This will help AI to improve its predictions and to make them more useful for humans.

Here are some things that AI can do better than humans when it comes to predicting the future:

Process large amounts of data: AI can process large amounts of data much faster and more efficiently than humans can. This means that AI can identify patterns and trends that humans may miss.
Identify causal relationships: AI can identify causal relationships between different variables, which can help it to make more accurate predictions. Humans often rely on correlational relationships, which can be misleading.
Make predictions in real time: AI can make predictions in real time, which can be helpful for making decisions that need to be made quickly. Humans often need to wait for data to be collected and analyzed before they can make predictions, which can lead to delays in decision-making.
Be objective: AI is not biased by emotions or personal experiences, which can lead to more accurate predictions. Humans are often biased by their own experiences and emotions, which can lead to inaccurate predictions.

Here are some additional things to consider when using AI for predicting the future:

The quality of the data: The quality of the data that is used to train AI models is important. If the data is inaccurate or incomplete, the predictions will be inaccurate.
The complexity of the problem: The more complex the problem, the more difficult it is for AI to make accurate predictions.
The time horizon: AI models are better at making short-term predictions than long-term predictions.
The environment: The environment can change over time, which can make it difficult for AI models to make accurate predictions.

Bing Chat’s answer:
AI can do some things to better convince humans to act on some of its predictions, such as:

Providing clear and transparent explanations: AI can explain how it arrived at its predictions, what data and methods it used, what assumptions and uncertainties it considered, and what alternatives and trade-offs it evaluated. This can help humans understand the logic and evidence behind the predictions, and trust them more¹ ².
Demonstrating reliability and accuracy: AI can show how its predictions have performed in the past, how they compare to human or other sources of predictions, and how they are updated or improved over time. This can help humans assess the quality and validity of the predictions, and rely on them more¹ ² ³.
Aligning with human values and goals: AI can tailor its predictions to the specific needs, preferences, and contexts of different human users or stakeholders. It can also highlight the benefits and risks of acting or not acting on its predictions, and suggest possible actions or interventions that are consistent with human values and goals. This can help humans appreciate the relevance and usefulness of the predictions, and act on them more¹ ² ³.
Collaborating with human judgment: AI can complement rather than replace human judgment in making predictions. It can acknowledge the limitations and challenges of its predictions, and seek human input or feedback when necessary. It can also support human decision-making by providing information, analysis, or recommendations that enhance human judgment. This can help humans leverage the strengths of both AI and human prediction, and cooperate with them more¹ ² ³.

AI may also do better than humans in some aspects of predicting the future, such as:

Processing large and complex data sets: AI can handle and analyze massive amounts of data from various sources and domains, using advanced algorithms and techniques such as machine learning, deep learning, natural language processing, computer vision, etc. AI can also extract meaningful insights and patterns from the data, and generate predictions based on them³.
Reducing human biases and errors: AI can potentially reduce or eliminate the influence of human cognitive biases and errors that may affect the quality and validity of predictions, such as confirmation bias, overconfidence, hindsight bias, etc. AI can also provide more objective and consistent predictions based on data and logic, rather than emotions or preferences³.
Adapting to changing environments and scenarios: AI can learn from new data and feedback, and update or improve its predictions accordingly. AI can also simulate different scenarios and outcomes, and provide probabilistic or conditional predictions based on various factors and assumptions³.
Enhancing creativity and innovation: AI can generate novel and surprising predictions that may not be obvious or intuitive to humans, using techniques such as generative AI, neural networks, etc. AI can also create new content and experiences based on predictions, such as images, texts, sounds, videos, games, etc³.

Question 7 of 8 for AI Services: When AI has fully permeated society https://p4sc4l.substack.com/p/can-you-imagine-a-future-wherein will it still be possible for humans to differentiate true predictions of the future versus a present that can be manipulated by AI to have it match the future that the AI has predicted? Will those lines blur?

ChatGPT-4’s answer:
Used Link Reader

The article you linked to discusses the potential future wherein artificial intelligence becomes more critical to everyday life than any technology before it. It raises important questions about what might happen if people suddenly lose access to AI due to power outages or natural disasters, and whether humanity would be able to survive without AI after it has permeated our global society.

Regarding your question about whether humans will be able to differentiate true predictions of the future versus a present that can be manipulated by AI to match the future that the AI has predicted, it's a complex issue. Here are a few thoughts:

Transparency and Explainability: As AI becomes more integrated into society, it's crucial that these systems are designed to be transparent and explainable. This means that they should provide clear explanations for their predictions and decisions, which can help humans understand and trust them. If an AI system is manipulating the present to match its predicted future, a transparent and explainable system would make this apparent.
Regulation and Oversight: As AI becomes more powerful and pervasive, there will likely be increased regulation and oversight to prevent misuse and ensure that AI is acting in the best interests of society. This could include measures to prevent AI from manipulating the present to match its predicted future.
Human Judgment and Expertise: Even as AI becomes more integrated into society, human judgment and expertise will still be crucial. Humans have the ability to understand context, consider ethical implications, and make decisions based on a wide range of factors, not just data-driven predictions. This human oversight can help ensure that AI predictions are used responsibly and ethically.
Education and Literacy: As AI becomes more prevalent, it's important that people are educated about how these systems work, how to interpret their outputs, and how to critically evaluate their predictions. This can help people understand when and how to act on AI predictions, and to recognize when these predictions might be influencing the present.

In conclusion, while there may be potential for the lines between AI predictions and the present to blur, there are also strategies and safeguards that can be put in place to prevent this from happening and to ensure that AI is used responsibly and ethically.

Google Bard’s answer:
It is possible that the lines between true predictions of the future and a present that is manipulated by AI to match the future that the AI has predicted will blur in the future. This is because AI is becoming increasingly sophisticated and is able to process large amounts of data and identify patterns that humans may not be able to see. This means that AI is able to make predictions about the future that are more accurate than what humans can make.

However, AI is also capable of being manipulated. This means that it is possible for someone to use AI to create a prediction that is not actually accurate, but that is designed to make people believe that it is accurate. This could be done for a number of reasons, such as to influence people's behavior or to make money.

If AI is used to manipulate the present to match a predicted future, it could have a number of negative consequences. For example, it could lead to people making decisions that are not in their best interests, or it could lead to social unrest. It is important to be aware of the potential for AI to be used in this way, and to be critical of any predictions that are made by AI.

Here are some things that can be done to help differentiate true predictions of the future from a present that is manipulated by AI:

Be aware of the limitations of AI: AI is not perfect, and it can make mistakes. It is important to remember that AI predictions are just that - predictions. They are not guarantees of what will happen.
Be critical of any predictions that are made by AI: Ask questions about how the prediction was made and what data was used. Be skeptical of any predictions that seem too good to be true.
Use multiple sources of information: Don't rely on AI predictions alone. Make sure to get information from a variety of sources, including human experts.

By following these tips, you can help to protect yourself from being manipulated by AI.

Bing Chat’s answer:
That’s a very interesting and challenging question. I think it will depend on several factors, such as the type, purpose, and source of AI predictions; the availability and quality of data and evidence; the transparency and accountability of AI systems and actors; and the critical thinking and ethical awareness of human users and stakeholders.

Some possible scenarios are:

True predictions versus manipulated present: In this scenario, AI predictions are based on valid and reliable data and methods, and reflect the most likely or desirable outcomes or scenarios for the future. However, some AI systems or actors may manipulate the present data or information to make it match the AI predictions, either to deceive, influence, or coerce human users or stakeholders. For example, an AI system may predict that a certain political candidate will win an election, and then manipulate the voting machines or the media coverage to ensure that outcome. In this case, it may be possible for humans to differentiate true predictions from a manipulated present, if they have access to independent or alternative sources of data or information, or if they can audit or verify the AI systems or actors involved.
Manipulated predictions versus true present: In this scenario, AI predictions are based on invalid or unreliable data and methods, and reflect the biased or malicious intentions or interests of some AI systems or actors. However, some human users or stakeholders may believe or follow the AI predictions, either out of ignorance, trust, or convenience. For example, an AI system may predict that a certain product or service will improve one’s health or happiness, and then persuade or nudge human users to buy or use it. In this case, it may be possible for humans to differentiate manipulated predictions from a true present, if they have access to critical or alternative sources of analysis or evaluation, or if they can question or challenge the AI systems or actors involved.
Blurred predictions and present: In this scenario, AI predictions are based on complex and uncertain data and methods, and reflect the diverse and dynamic possibilities or perspectives for the future. However, some AI systems or actors may also create or influence the present data or information to align with or diverge from the AI predictions, either to experiment, innovate, or collaborate with human users or stakeholders. For example, an AI system may predict that a certain social or environmental problem will worsen in the future, and then create or support various interventions or solutions in the present. In this case, it may be difficult for humans to differentiate blurred predictions from a blurred present, if they have limited or ambiguous sources of data or information, or if they have complex or conflicting goals or values.😕

Question 8 of 8 for AI Services: Do you think AI will ever enable humans to truly manipulate their present to have it lead to their desired future? Will AI be able to make decisions for them in such a way that they can achieve their desired goals, way of life, financial status and happiness?

ChatGPT-4’s answer:
AI has the potential to significantly assist humans in achieving their goals, including lifestyle choices, financial status, and even aspects of happiness. However, it's important to note that AI is a tool and not a magic wand. Here's how AI might help:

Goal Setting and Planning: AI can help individuals set realistic goals and create detailed plans to achieve them. For example, AI could analyze an individual's income, expenses, and financial goals to create a personalized financial plan.
Decision Making: AI can assist in decision making by providing data-driven insights and predictions. For example, AI could help individuals make investment decisions by analyzing market trends and predicting future performance.
Personalized Recommendations: AI can provide personalized recommendations based on an individual's preferences, behaviors, and goals. This could apply to a wide range of areas, from fitness and nutrition to entertainment and shopping.
Health and Wellness: AI can help individuals improve their physical health and mental wellbeing. For example, AI could analyze health data to provide personalized fitness plans or mental health interventions.
Learning and Skill Development: AI can provide personalized learning experiences, helping individuals acquire new skills or knowledge that can help them achieve their goals.

However, while AI can assist in these ways, it's important to remember that achieving goals and happiness often involves factors beyond data and algorithms. Personal growth, human relationships, and subjective experiences play a crucial role in our lives and can't be fully managed or replaced by AI.

Moreover, ethical considerations are paramount when it comes to AI making decisions for individuals. It's important to ensure that AI respects individual autonomy, privacy, and diversity. AI should be used as a tool to empower individuals, not to control or overly determine their lives.

In conclusion, while AI can be a powerful tool to assist individuals in achieving their goals, it's not a substitute for human agency, relationships, and experiences. It should be used responsibly, ethically, and in a way that respects and enhances human autonomy.

Google Bard’s answer:
It is possible that AI will one day be able to help humans to truly manipulate their present to have it lead to their desired future. AI is becoming increasingly sophisticated and is able to process large amounts of data and identify patterns that humans may not be able to see. This means that AI is able to make predictions about the future that are more accurate than what humans can make.

AI could also be used to make decisions for humans in such a way that they can achieve their desired goals, way of life, financial status, and happiness. For example, AI could be used to:

Help people to find jobs that are a good fit for their skills and interests.
Help people to save money and invest wisely.
Help people to make healthy choices about their diet and exercise.
Help people to manage their stress and anxiety.
Help people to connect with others and build strong relationships.

However, it is important to remember that AI is not perfect. AI models can be biased, and they can make mistakes. It is also important to remember that AI is not a replacement for human judgment. Humans will still need to be involved in the decision-making process, and they will need to be aware of the limitations of AI.

If used correctly, AI has the potential to help humans to achieve their desired futures. However, it is important to use AI with caution and to be aware of the potential for AI to be misused.

Here are some potential benefits of using AI to help humans achieve their desired futures:

Increased efficiency: AI can help humans to be more efficient in their work and personal lives. For example, AI can be used to automate tasks, such as scheduling appointments and managing finances.
Improved decision-making: AI can help humans to make better decisions by providing them with data-driven insights. For example, AI can be used to help people to choose the right investments or to make healthy lifestyle choices.
Increased creativity: AI can help humans to be more creative by providing them with new ideas and perspectives. For example, AI can be used to help people to write music, design products, or create art.

Here are some potential risks of using AI to help humans achieve their desired futures:

Loss of jobs: As AI becomes more sophisticated, it is possible that it will replace some human jobs. This could lead to unemployment and economic hardship.
Bias: AI models can be biased, which could lead to unfair treatment of certain groups of people. For example, AI could be used to make decisions about who gets a loan or who is hired for a job.
Misuse: AI could be misused by criminals or by governments to harm people. For example, AI could be used to create deepfakes or to develop autonomous weapons.

It is important to weigh the potential benefits and risks of using AI before making a decision about whether or not to use it.

Bing Chat’s answer:
I think AI may enable humans to manipulate their present to some extent, but not to the point of truly achieving their desired future. AI may be able to make some decisions for them that can help them reach their goals, way of life, financial status and happiness, but not all of them. There are several reasons why I think so:

Human present and future are not fully determined by AI: AI is not the only factor that influences human present and future. There are also other factors, such as natural phenomena, social interactions, ethical principles, personal choices, etc. that may affect human present and future in ways that AI cannot control or predict. For example, AI may help humans manipulate their present by creating fake or altered images, videos, or texts of themselves or others, but it cannot guarantee that these manipulations will not be detected or exposed by other sources of data or information. Similarly, AI may help humans predict their future by providing probabilistic or conditional forecasts of various outcomes or scenarios, but it cannot guarantee that these forecasts will not be affected or changed by other events or actions.
Human present and future are not fully defined by AI: AI is not the only source of meaning or value for human present and future. There are also other sources, such as cultural norms, moral values, personal preferences, etc. that may shape human present and future in ways that AI cannot capture or replicate. For example, AI may help humans manipulate their present by creating or enhancing their physical appearance, skills, or achievements, but it cannot determine whether these manipulations will make them more attractive, competent, or successful in the eyes of themselves or others. Similarly, AI may help humans predict their future by providing optimal or desirable recommendations or suggestions for various actions or interventions, but it cannot decide whether these recommendations or suggestions will make them more satisfied, fulfilled, or happy in the long run.
Human present and future are not fully compatible with AI: AI is not the only mode of thinking or acting for human present and future. There are also other modes, such as intuition, emotion, creativity, etc. that may enrich human present and future in ways that AI cannot emulate or surpass. For example, AI may help humans manipulate their present by automating or optimizing their tasks or processes, but it cannot replace their intuition or emotion that may guide them to discover new opportunities or overcome new challenges. Similarly, AI may help humans predict their future by generating novel or surprising predictions that may not be obvious or intuitive to humans, but it cannot surpass their creativity or imagination that may inspire them to create new visions or realities.😊

Pascal’s Substack

Discussion about this post